Bluff the Reader

Each Saturday Wait Wait Don’t Tell Me! The National Public Radio News Quiz includes a segment called “Bluff the Listener.”  Callers are challenged to tell truth from fiction.  Three stories are presented.  Only one is factual.  The stories usually feature politics, entertainment or sports.  So far they have, for unfathomable reasons, skipped the fertile ground of Baptist history.  What if they finally corrected this oversight?  Here are three stories of first Baptist churches.  Which is the one true tale?

Story one:  The first Baptist church in Maryland was a house that love built.  Six-principle foot-washing General Baptists began meeting in Lutherville, Maryland, in 1742.  Their third pastor, Henry Loveall, baptized forty-eight new converts shortly after coming.  Then the church began to hear rumors that Rev. Loveall was really Desolate Baker, a runaway indentured servant who was not only a criminal on the run, but fleeing justice in the intimate company of another man’s wife.  Rev. Loveall fled to a church in Virginia, but the rumors followed him, so he returned to Maryland.  Rev. Loveall watched his old church in Lutherville go from 181 members to 21.  He lived as proof that ministerial gifts and ministerial ethics don’t always go together—not even for Baptists named Rev. Loveall.  Was there really a pastor named Henry Loveall who wasn’t really named Henry Loveall?
Story two:  The first Baptist church in Pennsylvania began in 1764 with a captive audience.  Richard Curtis Sr. owned much of Asheville, North Carolina.  The senior Richard provided financial backing when his son, Richard Curtis, Jr. became pastor of a small Particular Baptist congregation, Mount Gilead.  Then Richard Jr. heard the Quaker John Woolman preach against slavery.  Richard Jr. was so taken with Woolman that he followed him back to Pennsylvania and became part of the Friends community, working to convince slaveholders to free their slaves.  Then Richard Sr. died and left his son fourteen slaves.  Richard Jr., under what he called “the clear urging of the Holy Spirit” founded a second Mount Gilead Baptist Church, this one in Philadelphia, the first Baptist church in Pennsylvania.  Was Mount Gilead Baptist Church in Philadelphia a church where the servants really were servants?

Story three:  The first Baptist church in Utah was the result of young love.  Dwight Spencer was the single pastor of Mount Olivet, a Free Will Baptist church in Denver, Colorado.  At a political event he met the beguiling Margaret Taylor, the daughter of Randolph Taylor, the pastor of First Methodist Church.  Dwight was smitten and asked Margaret to marry him.  Randolph Taylor forbid his daughter from marrying one of the “brigand Baptists,” so Dwight and Margaret eloped to Ogden, Utah.  Dwight began a Baptist church in a blacksmith shop in 1874 and was surprised when the congregation filled with Ute Indians.  Margaret didn’t care for Indian culture, but it was still a shock when Margaret left the Baptists for the Mormons, and Dwight for Gordon Fletcher, a Mormon elder.  A heartbroken Dwight resigned.  The First Baptist Church in Utah lasted only a few months.  They never had a joint worship service with the Mormons.  Is this a true story of big love in Utah?

Was the actual story Rev. Loveall’s church in Maryland discovering their pastor was loving all in an inappropriate way, Rev. Curtis’ inherited congregation in Pennsylvania or Rev. Spencer and his ex-Methodist, ex-Baptist ex-wife Mormon in Utah?  For the answer we turn to Loyd Allen’s page-turner of Baptist history You are a Great People:  “In the end, the Baptist story in Maryland does not rest heavily on the reputation of its earliest ordained ministers, but Baptist work was weakened by the scandal.  Eight years passed before another Baptist Congregation was established in Maryland.”

Congratulations to the many descendants of Henry Loveall, the residents of Lutherville and the church historians who answered correctly.

This entry was posted in Peculiar Preacher News. Bookmark the permalink.

294 Responses to Bluff the Reader

  1. Pingback: Church And Dwight

  2. Pingback: Alexander7

  3. Pingback: 325

  4. Pingback: 11325

  5. Pingback: s66s

  6. Pingback: Elektrorad beziehungsweise Elektrofahrrad

  7. Pingback: schnell abnehmen

  8. Pingback: ??????????? 2012

  9. Pingback: James

  10. Pingback: Find it here

  11. Pingback: ??? ????

  12. Pingback: ???? ???????????

  13. Pingback: best cat litter box

  14. Pingback: ???????? mild

  15. Pingback: ???????? rs

  16. Pingback: ???????? ???

  17. Pingback: facebook marketing

  18. Pingback: ???????? ffk

  19. Pingback: balance de cuisine

  20. Pingback: ????? paypal ????????????

  21. Pingback: ????? paypal????????????

  22. Pingback: snowboard

  23. Pingback: ??? ?????????

  24. Pingback: site

  25. Pingback:

  26. Pingback: Top Kids Apps

  27. Pingback: webblog

  28. Pingback: phone lookup

  29. Pingback: \adderall narcolepsy\

  30. Pingback: simulation credit immobilier

  31. Pingback: rachat de credits

  32. Pingback: credit logement

  33. Pingback: hardwood floor cost

  34. Pingback: Tarzan vibrator

  35. Pingback: ???????????????????

  36. Pingback: veterinary technician schools in ohio

  37. Pingback: radiology technician

  38. Pingback: \teaching jobs in special education\\

  39. Pingback: Geldspielautomaten

  40. Pingback: seo

  41. Pingback: colocation toulouse

  42. Pingback: lennot

  43. Pingback: ????????????

  44. Pingback: ????????????????

  45. Pingback: View Here

  46. Pingback: side effects of Tamoxifen

  47. Pingback: how to get your boyfriend back

  48. Pingback: Citalopram reviews

  49. Pingback: side effects of Percocet

  50. Pingback: URL

  51. Pingback: tv shows online for free

  52. Pingback: penis products

  53. Pingback: viagra alternative

  54. Pingback: african mango plus

  55. Pingback: phentermine 37.5

  56. Pingback: Get Quick Payday Loans Online

  57. Pingback: provestra libido enhancer

  58. Pingback: payday loans

  59. Pingback: nocredit check loans

  60. Pingback: quick quid loans

  61. Pingback: phen375 weight loss

  62. Pingback: payday loans

  63. Pingback: direct payday lenders

  64. Pingback: HealthStore is a nice Online Shopping Store for Health

  65. Pingback: Cabal rider

  66. Pingback: The Perfect Food Supplement For Your Health - Documentations

  67. Pingback: Rockell Starbux

  68. Pingback: Payday Loan

  69. Pingback: onlinekredit

  70. Pingback: Payday Loan

  71. Pingback: kredit ohne schufa

  72. Pingback:

  73. Pingback: loans

  74. Pingback: Privatkredit

  75. Pingback: Online Kredit

  76. Pingback: Kredit von Privat

  77. Pingback: loans for people with bad credit

  78. Pingback:

  79. Pingback: payday loan

  80. Pingback: maillot de foot france

  81. Pingback: vwqesdmxrq

  82. Pingback: lohuns

  83. Pingback: payday loan

  84. Pingback: Kredite ohne Schufa

  85. Pingback: instant loan

  86. Pingback: kreditverleichso4

  87. Pingback: kreditvergleich

  88. Pingback: privatkreditso4

  89. Pingback: kreditverleichso3

  90. Pingback: baukredit

  91. Pingback: Awesome Bags

  92. Pingback: Payday Loan

  93. Pingback: maillot de foot pas cher

  94. Pingback: fat loss factor

  95. Pingback:

  96. Pingback: create an app

  97. Pingback: No Credit Check Loans

  98. Pingback: google

  99. Pingback: nike tn

  100. Pingback: maillot psg 2013

  101. Pingback: louis vuitton paris

  102. Pingback: payday loans uk direct lenders

  103. Pingback: no credit check loans

  104. Pingback: ralph lauren pas cher

  105. Pingback: buy backlinks

  106. Pingback: travel deals

  107. Pingback: Semana

  108. Pingback: maillot de foot

  109. Pingback: maillot de foot pas cher

  110. Pingback: maillot chelsea 2013

  111. Pingback: simply click the following page payday loans

  112. Pingback: 90 day payday loans online

  113. Pingback: online payday loans direct lenders

  114. Pingback: Online Loan

  115. Pingback: lunette soleil homme

  116. Pingback: vente privee moncler

  117. Pingback: How to make an app

  118. Pingback: how to make money selling books online part v

  119. Pingback: supra lucca

  120. Pingback: seo company

  121. Pingback: mlsp review

  122. Pingback: precio manolo blahnik

  123. Pingback: new era 59fifty NFL cap

  124. Pingback: christian louboutins tumblr

  125. Pingback: the new new balance

  126. Pingback: christian louboutins bianca

  127. Pingback: nike air max 91

  128. Pingback: converses pas chere 1330

  129. Pingback: toma mbt calzados

  130. Pingback: Prezzi moncler uomo NEGOZI

  131. Pingback: nike free xt

  132. Pingback: air jordan flight 23

  133. Pingback: belstaff douglas blazer

  134. Pingback: chaussures adidas nouvelle collection

  135. Pingback: moncler bady black

  136. Pingback: celine dion tout seul testo

  137. Pingback: Nike Air Force liberation dates 2011

  138. Pingback: mbt store k?ln

  139. Pingback: supra bolzano

  140. Pingback: MBT saldi roma

  141. Pingback: nike free waffle 5.0

  142. Pingback: longchamp shopper günstig

  143. Pingback: maglioni ralph lauren

  144. Pingback: prezzi mbt scarpe

  145. Pingback: 9fifty snapback new era

  146. Pingback: purple nike blazers

  147. Pingback: moncler roma

  148. Pingback: Sandales Isabel Marant

  149. Pingback: childrens wall stickers

  150. Pingback: Nike Free 7

  151. Pingback: moncler kinder jacken

  152. Pingback: js wings 2.0

  153. Pingback: smanicato moncler

  154. Pingback: Moncler Vests Men

  155. Pingback: Where To Buy Steel 10s

  156. Pingback: moncler italie

  157. Pingback: moncler uomo prezzi

  158. Pingback: moncler shop online

  159. Pingback: moncler beanie

  160. Pingback: giubbotti donna moncler

  161. Pingback: moncler schweiz

  162. Pingback: moncler polo dames

  163. Pingback: moncler jackets sale

  164. Pingback: moncler maya

  165. Pingback: MONCLER jassen vrouwen

  166. Pingback: piumini donna moncler prezzi

  167. Pingback: air force 180

  168. Pingback: doudoune moncler discount

  169. Pingback: iq test

  170. Pingback: Gamma Blue 11s 2013

  171. Pingback: blouson moncler

  172. Pingback: timberland madrid

  173. Pingback: Sandales Isabel Marant

  174. Pingback: longchamp preis

  175. Pingback: fake moncler

  176. Pingback: Nike free Sverige

  177. Pingback: discount mbt

  178. Pingback: 2013 Isabel Marant pas cher

  179. Pingback: Jordan 11 Gamma Blue

  180. Pingback: Gamma Blue 11s For Sale

  181. Pingback: moncler torino

  182. Pingback: nike free 5.0 dame

  183. Pingback: moncler schuhe

  184. Pingback: cheapest mbt shoes

  185. Pingback: kreditvergleich online kostenlos

  186. Pingback: Free Piano

  187. Pingback: Outlet

  188. Pingback:

  189. Pingback: ralph lauren Outlet

  190. Pingback:

  191. Pingback:

  192. Pingback: cmscc POLO

  193. Pingback: Pandora Charms On Sale

  194. Pingback: charms

  195. Pingback: cheap louis vuitton handbags for sale

  196. Pingback: Ralph Lauren Skjorta

  197. Pingback:

  198. Pingback: pandora sale

  199. Pingback:

  200. Pingback:

  201. Pingback: How To Get Concord 11s

  202. Pingback: Authentic Concord 11s

  203. Pingback:

  204. Pingback: cheap ralph lauren

  205. Pingback:

  206. Pingback: Ralph Lauren® Italia Outlet

  207. Pingback: Ralph Lauren®

  208. Pingback: ralph lauren italia outlet

  209. Pingback: Ralph Lauren Pas cher

  210. Pingback:

  211. Pingback: elder scrolls online gold

  212. Pingback: camm polo

  213. Pingback: eso gold

  214. Pingback: Ralph Lauren outlet Italia

  215. Pingback: Cheap Ralph Lauren Canada

  216. Pingback: Cheap Ralph lauren Polo Shirts UK

  217. Pingback:

  218. Pingback:

  219. Pingback:

  220. Pingback: jeans

  221. Pingback: toms shoes outlet

  222. Pingback:

  223. Pingback: longchamp Sac à main en tissu Occasion - Très bon état

  224. Pingback: longchamp Sac à main en cuir Occasion - Bon état Noir

  225. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti London Croc Zip Sneakers

  226. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti London Croc Cha

  227. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti Star Motif Cowboy Boots Khaki Grey Short Boots

  228. Pingback:

  229. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti Golden Heel Wedge Cowboy Half Boots

  230. Pingback: Jordan 11 Low Concord

  231. Pingback: nike free run kids

  232. Pingback: Jordan 6 Retro Carmine

  233. Pingback: true religion online shop

  234. Pingback: Messi F50

  235. Pingback: Authentic Concord 11s

  236. Pingback: Jordan Oreo 5s

  237. Pingback: polo ralph lauren outlet

  238. Pingback: Hogan Online

  239. Pingback: Authentic Carmine 6s

  240. Pingback: chaussures nike tn requin

  241. Pingback: cheap louis vuitton

  242. Pingback:

  243. Pingback:

  244. Pingback: home

  245. Pingback: tiffany gioielli milano

  246. Pingback: Cheap True Religion Jeans

  247. Pingback: tiffany uk sale

  248. Pingback: burberry uk outlet

  249. Pingback: Crampons Nike Mercurial Vapor

  250. Pingback: UK

  251. Pingback:

  252. Pingback: FFXIV Gil

  253. Pingback: Chaussures De Football Nike Mercurial

  254. Pingback: cheap toms

  255. Pingback: Bottega Veneta Bag Outlet

  256. Pingback: louis vuitton bags uk

  257. Pingback: cheap ray ban

  258. Pingback: jordan 6 carmine

  259. Pingback: jordan 6 carmine

  260. Pingback: christian louboutin outlet

  261. Pingback: scarpe jordan online

  262. Pingback: Survetement Bresil

  263. Pingback: mulberry sales

  264. Pingback: jordan 6 carmine

  265. Pingback: toms for women cheap

  266. Pingback: carmine 6s

  267. Pingback: jordan 6 carmine

  268. Pingback: veste hollister femme

  269. Pingback: carmine 6s

  270. Pingback: Carmine 6s 2014

  271. Pingback: karen millen dresses

  272. Pingback: Jordan 6 Retro Carmine

  273. Pingback:

  274. Pingback: cheap designer chloe handbags

  275. Pingback: Hermes Sale

  276. Pingback: wow gold

  277. Pingback: pdf books

  278. Pingback:

  279. Pingback: ???????

  280. Pingback: online books free

  281. Pingback: ray ban da vista

  282. Pingback: wow gold

  283. Pingback: boutique louboutin

  284. Pingback: timberland boots sale

  285. Pingback: MCM ??

  286. Pingback: ???? ??

  287. Pingback: MCM ??

  288. Pingback: MCM ??

  289. Pingback: ???? ??

  290. Pingback: ?????? ???

  291. Pingback: ??????? 574

  292. Pingback: chanel ???

  293. Pingback: ???????

  294. Pingback: MCM iphone???

Comments are closed.